What Forex Brokers Don’t Want You to Know: Hidden Secrets Behind the Trades
- Hammet Forex
- Dec 11, 2024
- 6 min read
1. The Spread Can Be Wider Than It Seems
One of the primary ways forex brokers make money is through the spread — the difference between the buying and selling price of a currency pair. At first glance, the spread may appear low, but in reality, it can be much wider than advertised, particularly during periods of low market liquidity or high volatility.
Why Do Brokers Widen the Spread?
Market Conditions: Forex brokers typically widen their spreads during times of lower liquidity (like off-hours) or high volatility (during major economic releases). This makes trading more expensive for you, as you’ll need to pay a larger spread to enter and exit a position.
Hidden Costs: Some brokers advertise “tight spreads,” but the spreads can become much wider during periods of market turbulence, effectively increasing your transaction costs without your knowledge.
What You Can Do: Always check the spread during different market conditions. A reputable broker will show the “real” spread, especially during important economic releases or major market events.
2. Slippage: When Your Order Doesn’t Fill at the Expected Price
Slippage occurs when the price at which your order is executed is different from the price you expected. This can happen in both market orders (where you buy or sell immediately at the best available price) and stop orders (orders that trigger once a certain price level is reached). Brokers don’t always warn you about this, and in some cases, slippage can work against you, especially when the market is moving quickly.
Why Does Slippage Happen?
Volatility: During times of high volatility (e.g., during news announcements or significant economic events), price movements can be rapid, making it difficult for brokers to fill orders at the desired price.
Broker's Execution Model: Some brokers (particularly market makers) may intentionally widen slippage to their benefit. In this case, your loss is their gain. Brokers who use ECN (Electronic Communication Network) or STP (Straight Through Processing) models are typically less prone to this, but slippage can still occur.
What You Can Do: If slippage is a concern, make sure to choose a broker that offers an ECN or STP execution model, as these brokers tend to have better order fills. Additionally, always check the execution policies and conditions for slippage during volatile periods.
3. The Broker May Be Trading Against You (Conflict of Interest)
In the forex market, brokers operate under different business models. The most common are market maker and ECN/STP models. In a market maker model, brokers act as the counterparty to your trades, which means they profit when you lose.
How Do Market Makers Profit From Your Losses?
Counterparty to Your Trades: When you place a trade with a market maker broker, they are the ones who fill your order. Essentially, the broker takes the opposite side of your trade. If you’re betting on the price going up, the broker is betting on it going down — and vice versa.
Incentives to Manipulate: Some brokers have an incentive to see you lose, as they make money off your losses. They might even intentionally widen spreads, cause delays in execution, or engage in other tactics to increase your trading costs or induce poor decision-making.
What You Can Do: Opt for an ECN/STP broker, where orders are executed directly in the market, meaning the broker doesn’t take the opposite side of your trade. This eliminates the inherent conflict of interest found in market-making brokers.
4. Brokers Can Stop You Out Using “Stop Hunting”
Stop hunting refers to the practice of brokers or other market participants pushing the price of an asset to trigger stop-loss orders placed by retail traders. When enough stop-loss orders are triggered, the price can reverse sharply, allowing those who triggered the stops to profit. Some brokers, particularly market makers, have the ability to see where stop-loss orders are placed, and they may manipulate the market to trigger those stops and cause you to lose money.
How Does Stop Hunting Work?
Positioning and Knowledge: Market makers often have access to large volumes of order flow, allowing them to identify where the majority of traders have placed stop-loss orders. By intentionally pushing the market to these levels, brokers can trigger those orders and profit from the resulting price movement.
Market Manipulation: Some unscrupulous brokers may engage in stop hunting tactics, driving the market to hit stop-loss levels to liquidate positions and then reversing the price movement once retail traders are out.
What You Can Do: To minimize the risk of stop hunting, consider using wider stop-loss orders placed at logical technical levels (e.g., support and resistance). Avoid placing stop-losses at obvious levels where large numbers of traders may have their stops. You can also consider brokers who use ECN or STP models, which are less prone to such practices.
5. Hidden Fees and Inactivity Charges
Many forex brokers advertise "no commissions" or "zero fees," but this is often far from the truth. While they may not charge a direct commission, brokers often hide their fees in other areas.
Types of Hidden Fees You Might Encounter:
Swap/Overnight Fees: These are fees that apply if you hold a position overnight. Depending on the currency pair, these fees can be substantial, especially if you’re trading large positions.
Inactivity Fees: Some brokers charge an inactivity fee if your account remains unused for a certain period (usually 3 to 12 months). These fees can quickly eat into your profits or even your account balance.
Deposit and Withdrawal Fees: Some brokers charge fees for deposits or withdrawals, especially if you’re using certain payment methods.
What You Can Do: Always read the fine print and ask the broker about any hidden fees. Pay close attention to deposit/withdrawal methods and inactivity clauses in the terms and conditions. Using a broker with transparent fee structures can help you avoid unpleasant surprises.
6. Brokers Can Influence Price Quotes
In some cases, particularly with market maker brokers, the prices you see on your trading platform may not always reflect the real market prices. This is because market makers can influence the bid and ask prices they display on their platform, which may not exactly match the prices in the interbank market.
Why Do Brokers Do This?
Influencing Liquidity: Market makers control the liquidity in the market and might offer you prices that are worse than those available in the broader market. This can create an unfair trading environment where your execution costs are higher.
Price Rejection: Market makers may reject certain orders or widen the spread when you attempt to trade at certain price levels.
What You Can Do: Always ensure that you’re trading with an ECN or STP broker, where prices are provided directly from the interbank market, and you have access to true market conditions.
7. Brokers May Encourage Overtrading
Many brokers profit from your activity, and they often incentivize traders to make frequent trades by offering bonuses, promotions, or high leverage. However, overtrading can be extremely harmful to your trading account, leading to unnecessary losses.
How Do Brokers Encourage Overtrading?
Leverage: Offering high leverage is a common tactic used to encourage traders to open larger positions and make more trades than they normally would.
Bonuses and Promotions: Brokers may offer enticing sign-up bonuses or rebates, which can encourage traders to trade more frequently, even if it goes against their trading plan.
Frequent Trading Platforms: Some brokers offer sophisticated platforms and tools that might encourage frequent trading, especially by novice traders who don’t fully understand the risks.
What You Can Do: Be mindful of your trading habits and avoid getting caught in the cycle of overtrading. Stick to a clear trading plan and use leverage responsibly. Avoid brokers who incentivize excessive trading or offer bonuses that could cloud your judgment.
8. Your Broker May Be Making Money Off Your Losses
As a retail trader, you may not always be aware of how your broker is profiting from your trades. In fact, some brokers make money when you lose money. This creates an inherent conflict of interest, especially in the case of market maker brokers.
How Does This Work?
Spread Markup: Market makers may mark up the spread beyond what you see in the market, which directly profits them when you lose.
Requotes and Order Rejection: Brokers may intentionally reject orders or offer worse prices, effectively making a profit from your losses.
What You Can Do: Stick to brokers that use transparent pricing models, such as ECN or STP brokers, where there is no conflict of interest in your trades. Always research the broker’s fee structure, execution model, and reviews to ensure you’re dealing with a reputable company.
Conclusion: Be Informed and Choose Wisely
Not all forex brokers have your best interests at heart, and understanding the common practices and pitfalls that brokers may employ is key to protecting your profits and improving your trading experience. By choosing a broker with transparent pricing, fair execution, and ethical practices, you can minimize the risks and focus on what matters most: developing a successful trading strategy. Always read the fine print, ask questions, and be mindful of the hidden practices that could hurt your performance.
Comments